The dangers of driving a junk car
By Cash For Junk Cars Chicago Smart Tow IncFirst published Updated
What are the dangers of driving an old car?
The biggest dangers of driving an old car are worn brakes and tires, rust eating into brake lines and structural parts, exhaust leaks that let carbon monoxide into the cabin, and breakdowns in places you can’t wait out, like an icy shoulder or a flooded viaduct. Older cars also protect you less when a crash happens.
Here are all ten at a glance, with the one check that tells you most about each.
| Danger | Quick check |
|---|---|
| Brakes | Soft pedal, pulling to one side, grinding |
| Tires | Tread depth and the date code on the sidewall |
| Hidden rust | Brake lines, suspension mounts and frame from underneath |
| Exhaust leaks | Exhaust smell inside, louder rumble, headaches on drives |
| Winter strandings | Battery age and how hard it cranks on cold mornings |
| Flooded viaducts | Knowing your route’s low spots before a storm |
| Potholes | Clunks over bumps, a car that wanders on the highway |
| Crash protection | The car’s age and which safety features it has |
| Fire | Fuel smell, oil leaks, fuses that keep blowing |
| The money | How many repair bills in the last year |
If several rows describe your car, it may already meet the working definition of a junk car. The rest of this page is the detail behind each row.
1. Brakes that fade, pull or grind
Most crashes come down to the driver, not the car. NHTSA’s crash causation survey, which investigated crashes at the scene from 2005 to 2007, put the critical reason on the vehicle in only about 2 percent of cases. But inside that 2 percent, brake problems made up about 22 percent. (NHTSA is careful to say a critical reason isn’t the same thing as blame.)
On an old car, brakes wear in ways you stop noticing. The pedal sinks a little lower each month. The car drifts left when you stop hard. Rusted brake lines are the worse version, because a line that’s rotted through can leak fluid and leave you with a pedal that goes to the floor.
2. Tires that are bald, cracked or old
Tire and wheel problems were the largest named category of those vehicle-related crashes in the same NHTSA survey, at about 35 percent. AAA’s winter driving advice says tires with at least 4/32 of an inch of tread give the best stopping power and resistance to hydroplaning. An old car that sits a lot can have decent-looking tread on rubber that’s cracking from age, so look at the sidewalls as well as the grooves.
3. Rust you can’t see from the driver’s seat
Chicago winters mean salt, and salt means rust. AAA warns that road salt speeds up rust on a vehicle’s undercarriage, and that rust can weaken structural parts, brake lines and suspension systems. That’s what makes it dangerous rather than ugly. A rust bubble on a fender is cosmetic. Rot at a suspension mount or along a brake line is not, and you won’t see either one without getting under the car.
If you’re keeping the car another winter, the winter maintenance checklist for older cars covers how often to rinse the salt off.
4. Exhaust leaks and carbon monoxide
This is the one that can hurt you without the car ever moving badly. Old exhaust systems crack, rust through and come loose at the joints, and a leak under the cabin can let carbon monoxide inside.
The CDC calls carbon monoxide “an odorless, colorless gas that kills without warning.” Its list of common symptoms is headache, dizziness, weakness, upset stomach, vomiting, chest pain and confusion, which is easy to blame on a long day. The CDC also counts more than 400 Americans dying each year from unintentional CO poisoning not linked to fires (from every source, not just cars). Two rules from the CDC and the National Weather Service apply directly to old cars:
- Never run a car or truck inside a garage attached to a house, even with the garage door open.
- If you’re stuck in snow, clear the exhaust pipe before running the engine.
Can an exhaust leak make you sick?
Yes. If you get headaches or feel dizzy on drives and better once you’re out of the car, treat that as an exhaust problem until a mechanic tells you otherwise.
5. Getting stranded in the cold
A weak battery that gets you through October can quit on the first zero-degree morning, and an old car that dies on the Dan Ryan in January is a different problem from one that dies in a driveway. The National Weather Service’s advice for drivers stranded in a winter storm is to stay with the car, run the motor about 10 minutes each hour for heat, open a window a little while it runs, and clear snow from the exhaust pipe. That’s survivable. It’s also an evening nobody wants, and an unreliable car makes it more likely.
6. Stalling in a flooded viaduct
Chicago’s viaducts and underpasses collect water fast in a heavy storm. When the city’s emergency management office announced a flood watch in August 2025, it urged motorists to avoid driving through standing water on streets, viaducts and low-lying areas. The National Weather Service puts numbers on why: 12 inches of rushing water can carry away most cars, and 2 feet can carry away SUVs and trucks.
A car that already struggles to start is the worst one to have quit halfway through. The city’s advice if your car stalls in flood water is blunt: abandon it and find another route. What the water does to the car afterwards is covered in our guide to water damaged cars.
7. Potholes on a worn suspension
The Chicago Department of Transportation explains potholes as a freeze-thaw problem: water seeps into the pavement, expands when it freezes and contracts when it thaws, and traffic does the rest. CDOT says they show up most on arterial streets and under bridges and viaducts, where water collects.
New shocks and good tires soak up a pothole. Worn ones pass the hit straight to the wheel, the tire and the steering parts. On an old car, a hard winter of craters can turn a vague, wandering feel on the highway into a real steering problem.
8. Less protection when a crash happens
This is the danger nobody can fix with a repair. NHTSA looked at drivers involved in fatal crashes between 2005 and 2011 and found that, accounting for other crash factors, the driver of a vehicle 18 or more years old was 71 percent more likely to be killed than the driver of a vehicle 3 years old or newer. The same study puts the figure at 50 percent for vehicles 15 to 17 years old.
No repair closes that gap, which is why a car’s age deserves a place in the decision when it also needs brakes, tires or exhaust work.
9. Fire
The U.S. Fire Administration lists mechanical and electrical issues, along with crashes, as common causes of vehicle fires. On an old car, that means fuel lines gone brittle, oil leaking onto a hot exhaust, and wiring that’s been spliced and taped by three different owners. A fuel smell, a fresh oil puddle or a fuse that keeps blowing are reasons to get it looked at before the next drive, not after.
10. The money that keeps going in
Not a safety risk in the crash-test sense, but it’s how people end up driving cars they know aren’t safe. Each repair looks small on its own, so the brakes wait while the battery gets replaced, and the exhaust waits while the tires get patched. If that sounds familiar, the signs it’s time to junk your car will help you tally it honestly.
When an unsafe car should come off the road
If the brakes, the frame or the exhaust is the problem and the repair costs more than the car is worth, stop driving it. Don’t nurse it to a buyer, either. We collect junk cars where they’re parked, running or not, and the tow is free. You’re paid at pickup in cash or by Zelle, Cash App or another digital payment, and the offer doesn’t expire if you need a few days to empty the trunk.
You can get an offer through the quote form in two steps, or read more about the way we buy junk cars across Chicago and the suburbs.
Sources for this guide
- NHTSA, “Critical Reasons for Crashes Investigated in the National Motor Vehicle Crash Causation Survey” (DOT HS 812 115, February 2015): vehicle-related critical reasons (about 2 percent of crashes; tires and wheels about 35 percent and brakes about 22 percent of those).
- NHTSA, “How Vehicle Age and Model Year Relate to Driver Injury Severity in Fatal Crashes” (DOT HS 811 825, August 2013): 71 percent and 50 percent higher fatality likelihood by vehicle age.
- AAA Club Alliance, “7 Tips for Safe Winter Driving”: 4/32-inch tread advice.
- AAA, “AAA Warns Drivers: Winter Road Salt Can Cause Hidden Vehicle Damage” (February 18, 2026): salt, undercarriage rust, brake lines, structure and suspension.
- CDC, carbon monoxide poisoning basics: CO description, symptoms, deaths per year, attached-garage rule.
- National Weather Service, winter storm safety: advice for drivers stranded in a vehicle.
- City of Chicago OEMC, Flood Watch (August 12, 2025): avoid standing water on streets, viaducts and low-lying areas.
- City of Chicago, severe weather preparedness release (April 22, 2026): if your car stalls in flood water, abandon it.
- National Weather Service, “Turn Around Don’t Drown”: water depths that carry away cars, SUVs and trucks.
- Chicago Department of Transportation, Pothole Repairs: freeze-thaw cause; arterials, bridges and viaducts.
- U.S. Fire Administration, Vehicle Fire Safety: mechanical and electrical causes of vehicle fires.
Questions people ask
Do I have to drive my car to you if it isn't safe to drive?
No. The car goes on the truck where it's parked, so an unsafe car never has to be driven anywhere, and the tow costs you nothing.
Is an exhaust smell inside the car dangerous?
It can be. An exhaust smell in the cabin means exhaust is getting in, and the CDC describes carbon monoxide as odorless and colorless, so you can't judge the danger by how strong the smell is. Get the leak found before you keep driving.
Can I still sell a car with rusted brake lines or a rotted frame?
Yes. Rust damage, worn brakes and failed parts don't stop a sale to us. Describe the damage honestly when you ask for an offer and the price will reflect the car as it is.
Got a car you're done with? Send the year, make and model and we'll come back with an offer. Towing is free.
Get a free quote