Skip to content
Cash For Junk Cars Chicago Smart Tow Inc

8 junkyard scams and how to spot them

By Cash For Junk Cars Chicago Smart Tow IncFirst published Updated

What are the most common junkyard scams?

Most junkyard scams happen at two moments: when the car is weighed and when the truck is at your curb. The usual tricks are a light scale reading, a price cut over a “missing” converter or bald tires, a towing fee taken from a free tow, pressure to skip or blank the title, and payment promised for later.

Every one of them works the same way. You learn about the cost after you’ve cleared your afternoon, emptied the trunk and told the neighbor the car is finally going, so starting over feels worse than taking the loss. Knowing the eight moves in advance takes that pressure away.

If this is your first sale, the step-by-step Chicago guide walks through the whole thing in order. This page covers only the places it goes wrong.

The eight tricks, at the yard and at the curb

1. The scale that reads light

At a yard that pays by weight, the scale is the price. The tricks are simple: a reading you never get to see, a ticket that never gets printed, or a weight quoted on the phone (“that model’s lighter than people think”) that you have no way to check.

The check: stand where you can see the display and ask for the printed ticket before you take any money. In Illinois, a scrap processor that takes in a car records the seller’s ID and the VIN on its weight ticket (625 ILCS 5/5-401.3), so a ticket should exist. If a buyer who comes to you prices by weight, ask what weight they used and where it came from.

2. The price that drops once the truck is there

The driver walks around the car, crouches to look underneath, and the number falls. The catalytic converter is “missing” or “aftermarket”. The tires are bald. There’s fuel in the tank, or fluids “we have to charge to dispose of”.

Some of this can be fair. If thieves cut the converter off last month and nobody noticed, the car really is worth less than the one you described. It’s a trick when the problem is something you already mentioned on the call, or something that was never part of how the number was worked out.

The check: say what’s on and off the car before you book (converter, wheels, battery, any missing panels), then ask one question: “What would change this number when you see it?” A straight buyer can answer that. Phone photos of the underside and the tires take two minutes and settle most arguments.

3. “Free towing” that costs something at pickup

The ad says the tow is free. At the curb there’s a hook-up fee, a dispatch fee or a fuel charge, or the payment is simply smaller “because of the tow”. Same result: you paid for towing.

The check: ask, word for word, “Is anything taken off for towing, at all?” and get the answer in a text. With us the tow is free and nothing comes off the offer to cover it.

4. “Don’t worry about the title,” or “just sign it and leave the rest”

This one comes in two forms. One buyer tells you no papers are needed, whatever the car. Another asks you to sign the seller’s line and leave the buyer’s name blank.

The first is a problem because the rules depend on the state, and they’re stricter than “no papers”. In Indiana, the seller has to give the recycler the title or a BMV certificate of authority (IC 9-22-5-18) whatever the car’s age; a recycler can take a car without a title only if it’s 15 or more model years old and the certificate comes with it, and buying one under 15 model years old with neither paper is a Level 6 felony for the buyer (IC 9-32-9-29). In Illinois, a scrap processor can’t take a vehicle without documentary proof such as a title, salvage certificate, junking certificate or Secretary of State junking manifest (5-401.3, linked above). Tell us which papers you have and we’ll confirm on the call whether they work for your car.

The blank buyer line is a problem for you. Illinois has the seller assign the title to the buyer in the space on the certificate (625 ILCS 5/3-112). Leave it empty and the car can be passed along again with your name still the last one anybody wrote down.

The check: the buyer’s business name goes on the buyer’s line, and you photograph the signed title before handing it over. Which papers a junk car sale needs sets out both states side by side.

5. “We’ll pay you when it’s processed”

The car gets loaded, and the money is promised for Friday, or after the car is weighed at the mill, or after it sells. Once the truck turns the corner, you have nothing left to bargain with.

The check: payment before the car moves. Ours happens at pickup, before the truck pulls away, in cash or by Zelle, Cash App or another digital payment.

6. The check that clears, then doesn’t

A paper check feels like payment. The FTC’s warning about fake checks explains why it isn’t yet: banks have to make deposited funds available quickly, but seeing the money in your account doesn’t mean the check is good, and if it turns out to be fake you’re the one who repays the bank (FTC). By then the car is long gone.

The check: take cash, or a transfer you’ve watched arrive, before the car is hooked up.

7. “Leave the plates on, we’ll take care of them”

They’re your plates, and taking them off is your job in both states. In Illinois, the registration expires when you transfer the car, and the owner removes the plates and stickers to send them to the Secretary of State or move them to another vehicle (625 ILCS 5/3-501). Indiana’s rule is the same in substance: the person transferring the car removes the plate and the registration (IC 9-18.1-4-6). A car that leaves with your plates can collect tickets and tolls under your name.

The check: have a screwdriver ready and take the plates off yourself before the car is loaded.

8. “This price is only good right now”

“Sign now or I’m leaving, and the price goes with me.” Or, on the phone, an offer that expires in an hour. The deadline is the trick. It’s there so you don’t stop to check the title, the plates or how you’re being paid.

The check: a fair number survives an afternoon of thinking it over. Ours doesn’t expire, so you can book the pickup when you’re ready.

How do you tell legit junk car buyers from the rest?

Legit junk car buyers answer four questions plainly before they send a truck: what the offer assumes, whether anything comes off for towing, when and how you’re paid, and which papers your state needs. Vague answers to any of the four are the warning sign. So is a buyer who asks nothing about you or the car.

What to check A straight answer sounds like A warning sign sounds like
The offer A number, plus what it assumes about the car “We’ll see when we get there”
Towing Free, nothing taken off “Just a small hook-up fee”
Payment At pickup, before the car moves “After it’s processed,” or a check in the mail
Papers Asks what you have and explains your state’s rule “You don’t need anything,” or “leave the buyer line blank”
Your ID Asks for it Doesn’t care who you are
Plates Expects you to take them “Leave them on”

A business name you can look up, with reviews you can read, adds a lot. We’d rather be checked than trusted, so who we are and how a pickup goes is written up in one place, and what past sellers wrote is on our Google listing for anyone to read.

What if the price changes at the curb?

Say no. Until you’ve signed and been paid, the car is still yours, and a buyer who won’t honor the number can leave without it. Getting a fresh quote takes a phone call, which is a lot less than the money a bad deal costs.

Where to go from here

Scams are the buyer’s side of things. Sellers trip themselves up too, usually by guessing the car’s details or leaving the papers until the last minute, and the seller-side mistakes cover nine of them with a fix for each. If you’re still deciding where to sell, the main types of buyer compared shows what a junkyard, a scrap yard and a pickup buyer each need from you.

When you want a number to hold the others against, send the car’s details or call (708) 663-1010, 6 a.m. to 9 p.m. Central any day of the week. How we buy junk cars lays out the rest: free towing, payment at pickup and the towns we cover.

Sources for this guide

Questions people ask

Is it a scam if the junk car price drops when the tow truck shows up?

Not always, but it should make you stop. A lower number is fair when the car really differs from what you described, and it's a trick when the driver finds a problem with something you already mentioned or that was never part of the quote. You can refuse and keep the car.

Should I sign the title before I get paid for my junk car?

No. Sign once the payment is in your hand or has landed in your account, and put the buyer's business name on the buyer's line rather than leaving it blank.

Can a junkyard pay me later or by check?

It can, but you carry the risk. Once the car is gone you have nothing to hold back, and the FTC warns that a deposited check can show as available and still bounce weeks later, leaving you to repay the bank.

Got a car you're done with? Send the year, make and model and we'll come back with an offer. Towing is free.

Get a free quote
Get offer Call