The most expensive car repairs
By Cash For Junk Cars Chicago Smart Tow IncFirst published Updated
What are the most expensive car repairs?
The most expensive car repairs are a transmission replacement, an engine replacement, a hybrid battery, a head gasket and a catalytic converter. RepairPal’s averages, updated September 3, 2026, put a transmission at $6,238 to $6,764 and a hybrid battery at $4,856 to $5,053. J.D. Power and ConsumerAffairs both put an engine replacement at $2,000 to $10,000.
Every figure on this page comes with its source and date, and each repair below is backed by two sources we opened. Where two sources didn’t agree closely enough to call a number confirmed, we left it out rather than guess. And if a quote like these has you wondering whether the car has crossed over into junk, what makes a car junk explains how junk, salvage and scrap differ under Illinois law.
Repair costs side by side
| Repair | Typical range | Source | Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| Transmission replacement | $6,238 to $6,764 (national average) | RepairPal | Sept. 3, 2026 |
| Transmission replacement | $2,500 to $5,000 (mainstream car, automatic, parts and labor) | J.D. Power | July 30, 2023 |
| Engine replacement | $2,000 to $10,000 | ConsumerAffairs | May 28, 2026 |
| Engine replacement | $2,000 to $10,000 | J.D. Power | Mar. 10, 2025 |
| Hybrid battery | $4,856 to $5,053 (national average) | RepairPal | Sept. 3, 2026 |
| Hybrid battery | $3,000 to $5,000 (Toyota Camry Hybrid) | J.D. Power | Mar. 20, 2023 |
| Head gasket | $2,572 to $3,386 (national average) | RepairPal | Sept. 3, 2026 |
| Head gasket | $1,000 to $3,000 | J.D. Power | July 6, 2023 |
| Catalytic converter | $2,280 to $2,480 (national average) | RepairPal | Sept. 3, 2026 |
| Catalytic converter | $933 to $4,414 (five mechanics, three sample cars) | ConsumerAffairs | Sept. 3, 2026 |
A few things to know before you read too much into one row. RepairPal’s ranges are national averages that leave out taxes, fees and your location, so a Chicago-area quote may land above or below them. The J.D. Power and ConsumerAffairs figures are typical spreads rather than averages, so they run wider. And two rows measure something narrower: J.D. Power’s hybrid number is for one model, and ConsumerAffairs’ converter range comes from its own survey of mechanics quoting three specific cars.
Transmission replacement: rebuilt, remanufactured, used or new
The transmission tops the ranking ConsumerAffairs built from RepairPal’s data in April 2026. But “replace the transmission” can mean four different jobs at four different prices, and the quote you get depends on which one the shop has in mind.
- Rebuilt: your own transmission is taken apart, the failed parts are replaced and it goes back in. Kelley Blue Book calls this the less costly of the two main routes, and it can be done in a local shop.
- Remanufactured: a transmission restored to factory standards on a factory line, which KBB says is the more expensive route.
- Used: a unit pulled from another vehicle, with whatever history that vehicle had.
- New: a new unit from the manufacturer or a parts supplier.
| Option | Range | Source | Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rebuilt | $2,000 to $3,500 (simpler four-speed) | Transmission shop owner quoted by ConsumerAffairs | Oct. 6, 2026 |
| Rebuilt | $1,580 to $4,020 | Street Smart Transmission | No date on page; read Oct. 6, 2026 |
| Rebuilt | $1,800 to $4,000 and up | Monster Transmission | No date on page; read Oct. 6, 2026 |
| Remanufactured | $1,950 to $4,200 (unit plus installation) | Street Smart Transmission | No date on page; read Oct. 6, 2026 |
| Remanufactured | $2,800 to $5,500 and up (unit) | Monster Transmission | No date on page; read Oct. 6, 2026 |
| Used | Left out: the two figures we found were too far apart to confirm | CostHelper, Monster Transmission | No dates on pages |
| New | $2,900 to $7,100 | Kelley Blue Book | No date on page; read Oct. 6, 2026 |
| New | $4,000 to $8,000 and up (new or OEM unit) | Monster Transmission | No date on page; read Oct. 6, 2026 |
Street Smart Transmission and Monster Transmission sell transmissions, so treat their ranges as a seller’s planning figures. Monster’s figures are for the transmission itself; its page says labor, shipping, fluid and other extras can push the total higher. RepairPal’s $6,238 to $6,764 average doesn’t say which type of unit it assumes; it falls inside both “new” ranges above.
Signs a transmission is failing
Kelley Blue Book, J.D. Power and ConsumerAffairs list much the same symptoms:
- Slow or no movement after you shift into Drive or another forward gear.
- Slipping: the engine revs higher but the car slows down or doesn’t pick up speed.
- Noises when shifting: grinding, clunking, whining or buzzing.
- Bucking, jerking or erratic shifts, and a burning smell or fluid leaking under the car.
None of those proves the transmission is gone. RepairPal points out that a bad wheel speed sensor or ignition coil can mimic transmission failure, and says a transmission should always be diagnosed before it’s replaced. The transmission shop owner ConsumerAffairs interviewed, Steve Sargent, said about half the people who come in with transmission symptoms have a problem caused by something else, and about half the transmission problems his shop sees are repairable. A specialist’s diagnosis can be worth more than the quote it replaces.
Is it worth replacing a transmission?
It’s worth replacing a transmission when the car will be worth clearly more than the bill once the work is done, and nothing else big is waiting behind it. On a low-value car it usually isn’t, a point ConsumerAffairs makes too. The test takes four steps:
- Get it diagnosed by a transmission specialist, not just a general shop.
- Price the options, rebuilt against remanufactured, with installation included in both.
- Look up the car’s value as if the work were done, for example with KBB’s Repair or Replace Advisor, which compares an estimate with the car’s Blue Book value.
- Add the other repairs it needs. Sargent’s own example was telling a customer not to spend the money on a transmission because the engine had issues and the car needed tires.
If the quote eats most of the car’s fixed value, the job buys back the same old car for more than it’s worth. Whether scrapping a car is worth it runs that math in full, against the 70% repair-cost line Illinois uses for self-insured companies’ vehicles, and the cost of keeping a dead car registered in Chicago.
Engine replacement
ConsumerAffairs and J.D. Power both put a typical engine replacement at $2,000 to $10,000, and J.D. Power adds that the range can skew higher for luxury and high-end sports cars. As with transmissions, a shop may offer a new, remanufactured, used or rebuilt engine, and the price swings with the choice. J.D. Power also notes a quirk worth knowing: an older engine that was built for years can be cheaper to source than one from a recent model, simply because more of them are out there.
Hybrid battery
RepairPal’s national average for a hybrid high-voltage battery is $4,856 to $5,053. J.D. Power’s figure for a Toyota Camry Hybrid is $3,000 to $5,000. On an older hybrid, check that number against what the car is worth before anything else, because it’s a single bill for a single part. A long battery warranty may still cover it, and whether to replace a dead hybrid battery or junk the car starts with that check.
Head gasket
RepairPal puts a head gasket replacement at $2,572 to $3,386 on average; J.D. Power’s range is $1,000 to $3,000. The gasket itself is a cheap part. The cost is in the hours it takes to get to it, and both RepairPal’s breakdown and ConsumerAffairs put most of the bill in labor. ConsumerAffairs lists engine overheating first among the causes, and it also lists a blown head gasket among the causes of a cylinder head replacement, so ask whether the head itself was checked.
Catalytic converter
RepairPal’s national average is $2,280 to $2,480. ConsumerAffairs surveyed five mechanics on three sample cars and got averages from $933 to $4,414, with the most expensive being a 2017 Honda Civic rather than the BMW in the group. Theft is one reason converters get replaced; contamination from engine problems and overheating are others.
When junking beats repairing
One of these repairs on a car that’s otherwise sound can be worth paying for. Two of them, or one on a car with rust, high miles and worn tires, usually isn’t. If the car has already stopped running and you don’t yet know why, rule out the cheap causes first with what to do when an old car won’t start. Damage from outside the car can tip the balance too: wiring chewed by rats is usually an insurance question before it’s a repair one.
If the numbers say stop, we buy cars with the failure still in them: a slipping transmission, a blown head gasket, an engine that won’t turn over. The tow is free, and you’re paid at pickup, in cash or through a digital payment such as Zelle or Cash App. Our offer doesn’t expire, so you can get a quote for the car as it sits and hold it next to the mechanic’s estimate. The home page sums up how we buy junk cars, from the pickup area to the hours the phones are on.
Sources for this guide
- RepairPal, Transmission Replacement Cost Estimate (estimates last updated September 3, 2026): $6,238 to $6,764, excluding taxes, fees and location; diagnosis advice.
- RepairPal, Hybrid High Voltage Battery Replacement Cost Estimate (September 3, 2026): $4,856 to $5,053.
- RepairPal, Head Gasket Replacement Cost Estimate (September 3, 2026): $2,572 to $3,386, with labor above parts.
- RepairPal, Catalytic Converter Replacement Cost Estimate (September 3, 2026): $2,280 to $2,480.
- J.D. Power, “How Much Does It Cost To Replace A Transmission On A Car?” by Dustin Hawley, July 30, 2023: $2,500 to $5,000 for a mainstream automatic; symptoms.
- J.D. Power, “How Much Does It Cost to Replace an Engine?” by Peter Nelson, March 10, 2025: $2,000 to $10,000; luxury cars and supply.
- J.D. Power, “How Much Does A Camry Hybrid Battery Replacement Cost?” by Dustin Hawley, March 20, 2023: $3,000 to $5,000.
- J.D. Power, “How Much Does It Cost To Replace A Head Gasket?” by Dustin Hawley, July 6, 2023: $1,000 to $3,000.
- ConsumerAffairs, “How Much Does a Transmission Cost?” updated October 6, 2026: Steve Sargent’s rebuild range, diagnosis figures and repair-or-replace advice; symptoms.
- ConsumerAffairs, “How Much Does It Cost to Replace an Engine?” updated May 28, 2026: $2,000 to $10,000; engine options.
- ConsumerAffairs, “Cost to Replace a Catalytic Converter,” updated September 3, 2026: the five-mechanic survey, $933 to $4,414.
- ConsumerAffairs, “Most Expensive Car Repairs,” updated April 11, 2026: transmission replacement ranked first of 349 repairs in RepairPal data; head gasket cost mostly labor; causes of converter and head gasket failure.
- Kelley Blue Book, Transmission Repair and Replacement: $2,900 to $7,100 for a new transmission; rebuilt and remanufactured defined; symptoms.
- Kelley Blue Book, “Do I Need a New Transmission?” by Regina Yu, updated August 6, 2026: warning signs of transmission failure.
- Kelley Blue Book, Repair or Replace Advisor: compares a repair estimate with the car’s Blue Book value.
- Street Smart Transmission, Transmission Rebuild Cost: rebuild $1,580 to $4,020; remanufactured $1,950 to $4,200 installed.
- Monster Transmission, “How Much Is a Transmission?”: rebuilt, remanufactured, used and new planning ranges.
- CostHelper, Cost of Replacing a Transmission: used transmission figures (not used: they didn’t match the other source).
Got a car you're done with? Send the year, make and model and we'll come back with an offer. Towing is free.
Get a free quote