Skip to content
Cash For Junk Cars Chicago Smart Tow Inc

9 mistakes people make selling a junk car

By Cash For Junk Cars Chicago Smart Tow IncFirst published Updated

What are the biggest mistakes people make selling a junk car?

The biggest mistakes people make selling a junk car are paying for repairs first, guessing the car’s details for the quote, pulling parts without saying so, and leaving the papers and plates until the truck is outside. Each one costs money or a wasted pickup, and each has a fix you can do before you call.

Here are all nine at a glance, with the fix next to each.

The mistake The fix
Paying for repairs before selling Get the as-is offer first
Junking a car a private buyer would want Sell good runners privately
Guessing the details for the quote Read them off the papers and test the car
Stripping parts without saying so Decide first, then tell the buyer
Hunting for the title after booking Find your papers before you call
Letting a dead car sit on a Chicago street Book the pickup before the city acts
Plates off at the wrong time Remove them when the truck is there
Leaving your things in the car A ten-minute sweep with a bag
Taking the first number blind Ask what the number includes

If you’d rather see the whole sale in the right order first, how to junk a car in Chicago goes step by step. The rest of this page is about the places sellers lose money along the way.

The nine mistakes, and what to do instead

1. Should you fix a junk car before you sell it?

Usually not. Paying for repairs first is how sellers throw good money after a car that’s leaving anyway. A junk car buyer prices what’s in front of them: the metal, the parts that still sell, the papers. A new starter or a fresh set of brakes rarely comes back to you in that number, because the car is headed for dismantling either way.

The fix: get the as-is offer before you spend anything. A repair only makes sense if you plan to keep driving the car or sell it privately, and then the test is the repair bill against what the car would be worth running. Whether scrapping is worth it works through that comparison.

2. Junking a car that a private buyer wants

The opposite mistake. A car that starts every morning, passes inspection and has years left in it will usually bring more from a private buyer than from anyone who buys junk. We’d tell you the same on the phone.

The fix: be honest about which kind of car you’ve got. Runs well and worth fixing? List it. Won’t start, wrecked, flooded, burned or missing half its parts? That’s the car a junk buyer is for.

3. Guessing the details for the quote

A quote is only as good as the description behind it. Getting the year wrong by a couple, saying “it runs” when it runs only with a jump, forgetting the flood last spring: each one turns into a surprise at the curb, and a surprise is the easiest excuse for a lower number.

The fix: read the year, make and model off the registration or title instead of from memory. Try to start the car on the day you call. Say whether you have the keys (no keys is fine; tell us so the truck comes ready) and mention any fire, flood or crash damage.

4. Should you take parts off before the car goes?

You can, but only if you say so before the quote. The mistake is pulling the battery, the catalytic converter or the good wheels after you’ve agreed a price for a complete car, or swapping decent tires for bald ones the night before. The driver will notice, and the number will move.

The fix: decide what stays before you ask for an offer, then tell the buyer exactly what’s gone. If thieves took the converter, say that too. It isn’t your fault, but it changes the car, and hearing it on the phone beats finding it on the street.

5. Hunting for the title after the truck is booked

Plenty of sellers book the pickup and then start looking for the title. If it’s lost, the day falls apart.

The fix: find your papers before you call: title, registration, bill of sale, anything with the car on it. In Indiana, a lost title can be replaced with a BMV duplicate for $15 (BMV fee chart), and the BMV’s certificate of authority (State Form 55018, $4 on the same chart) is the other paper a recycler can accept; which one fits depends on the car’s age, and we’ll tell you on the call. In Illinois, tell us what you have and we’ll confirm whether it works for a scrap sale. What paperwork you need to junk a car covers both states, with the statutes linked.

6. Letting a dead car sit on a Chicago street

This is the mistake that ends with nothing at all. The City of Chicago can classify a car as abandoned if it sits on a public way unable to be driven, hasn’t moved in more than seven days and looks deserted, or has been there without state registration for two or more days. Abandoned cars are towed to a city auto pound and, if the owner doesn’t redeem them, sold for scrap (City of Chicago).

The fix: get it into a driveway or garage if you can, or book the pickup before it reaches those marks. The suburbs set their own rules, and many of the town pages listed under every town we cover go through the local parking limits.

7. When should the plates come off?

When the truck is there, not days before and not never. Leaving them on is the common version: in Illinois the registration expires when you transfer the car and the owner removes the plates and stickers (625 ILCS 5/3-501), and Indiana puts the same job on the seller (IC 9-18.1-4-6). Pulling them early is the Chicago version, because a car on the street without registration for two days fits the city’s abandoned-vehicle list from mistake 6.

The fix: have a screwdriver ready and take them off while the driver is there. Call your insurer the same day the car goes, not before it leaves and not a month later.

8. Leaving your things in the car

Once the car is loaded, it’s on its way to being taken apart, and nobody is going to mail you the garage remote.

The fix: spend ten minutes with a bag before the truck comes. Check the glovebox (old registration and insurance cards carry your address), the sun visors, the seat pockets, under the seats and under the trunk floor. Take the toll transponder off the windshield, or take that plate off your toll account. Car seats, phone mounts, chargers and parking permits go too.

9. Taking the first number without asking what’s in it

A number on its own tells you very little. One buyer’s figure has a towing charge hidden inside it; another is paid “after processing”. Neither is the number it sounds like.

The fix: ask three things before you say yes. Is anything taken off for towing? When and how am I paid? What would change this number when you see the car? With us the tow is free, the payment comes at pickup in cash or by Zelle, Cash App or another app transfer, and the offer doesn’t expire. The buyer-side tricks are in eight junkyard scams and the checks that stop them.

Before you call

If this is your first time selling a car for scrap, the questions first-time sellers ask covers plates, insurance, taxes and what happens to the car after the tow. When you’re ready, get an offer with the year, make, model and the papers you’ve found, and what we buy and where we pick up has the rest, from Chicago and the Cook, DuPage and Will County suburbs to Northwest Indiana as far as Gary.

Sources for this guide

Got a car you're done with? Send the year, make and model and we'll come back with an offer. Towing is free.

Get a free quote
Get offer Call